The Four Pillars of Selling: How to Convert the Leads You Already Have with David Haimes
Most founders are better at generating leads than they realise. The real opportunity, and often the real gap, is what happens next. In our most recent Mastermind session, we turned our attention to sales conversion: the part of the business development process that, when improved, adds real growth to your business without spending an extra penny on marketing.
David Haimes, former CEO of Obika and MD of Itsu, guides our flagship mastermind group through a session at the start of each month focusing on a pressing business challenge. Being an experienced sales and business growth coach who has worked with thousands of founders across a wide range of industries, this topic seemed apt. What followed was an honest, practical conversation that challenged a few assumptions and gave every member in the room something concrete to go away and change.
An Honest Confession about Conversion Rates
The session opened with a simple question: do you know what your conversion rate is?
The answers ranged from confident estimates to refreshing admissions of “not really.” And that, as David pointed out, is entirely normal. When you ask a founder their conversion rate, they’ll usually say it’s great. But when you measure it for a couple of months, the data tells a different story. We tend to forget the leads we didn’t follow up on, the ones who said no, and the ones who simply disappeared. The numbers are rarely as strong as we think.
This matters because improving your conversion rate is one of the simplest forms of business growth. If you move from 50% to 60%, you’ve added 10% growth to your revenue, and in most cases, it costs nothing to achieve. It’s often a technique and process problem, not a budget issue.
*Step one is simply to start measuring your conversion rate, broken down by lead type and tracked month on month. The act of measuring alone tends to improve performance, because it becomes a challenge you can’t ignore.
The Psychology Behind Every Sale
Before getting into process, David made one thing clear: sales is psychology. It always has been.
All of the research points in the same direction: people buy on emotion and rationalise their decision afterwards. The Range Rover that you convinced yourself you needed because of the kids. The expensive experience you booked because, rationally, it would ‘broaden your horizons.’ We construct logical justifications, but the initial impulse is almost always emotional. Understanding this changes everything about how you approach the sale.
With that notion as the foundation, David introduced a framework he’s refined over years of working with growing businesses: the Four Pillars. Think of them as the four emotional stages every buyer moves through before they’re ready to commit. Miss one, and you won’t convert. Move through all four, and the sale will feel almost effortless.
Pillar One: Know, Like and Trust
Before anyone buys anything, they need to feel a degree of familiarity, warmth and confidence in who they’re buying from. This isn’t just about having a polished website or a well-crafted pitch. It’s building a genuine emotional bond between your customer and your brand.
For most businesses, this happens across three or four touch-points. A potential customer might see you on social media, then have a phone call, then meet you in person. Each interaction is a deposit in what David calls the ‘emotional bank account.’ By the time you’re sitting face-to-face, the groundwork should already be laid.
For higher-value purchases, the more in-person communication you can build into this stage the better. The higher the price tag, the more know, like and trust is required before someone will commit. For businesses operating at volume and lower price points, this stage has to be done digitally, which means your brand story, your social proof, and your consistency of presence matter enormously.
One member in the group shared that for many of their corporate clients, the emotional driver isn’t excitement – it’s the removal of risk. Their buyers aren’t hoping the product or service will be wonderful; they’re hoping it won’t go wrong and reflect badly on them. Stories of seamless delivery and consistent quality aren’t just nice to have…they are the product.
Pillar Two: Understand the Emotional Need
This is by far the most underestimated pillar, and probably the one with the most room for improvement in the majority of small businesses.
David drew a clear distinction between situational questions and emotional questions. Situational questions: ‘when’s your event?’, ‘how many people are attending?’, ‘what’s your budget?’ are things you need to know, but they’ll never convert into a sale on their own. They don’t dig deep enough to find the real reason someone is buying.
Emotional questions go much deeper: ‘What would it mean to you personally if this worked?’ ‘What would be the implication for you – your career, your reputation, your life – if this exceeded your expectations?’ Once you get to that, you’ve found the bullseye. And once you find the bullseye, you know exactly where to aim.
One member in the group shared a conversation they’d had with a prospective client the previous day. By asking the right questions, they discovered that the person really wanted was to step back from the day-to-day running of their business, bring in a new CEO eventually, so they could shift into a different role. That single insight transformed the entire conversation. Rather than listing features and benefits, they could respond to what the person cared about.
If you haven’t found the emotional need, you’ll know because you’ll keep being met with objections. ‘I’ll think about it.’ ‘Send me some more information.’ These aren’t hurdles; they’re signals that you’ve skipped a step.
Pillar Three: Help, Don’t Sell
Once you understand the emotional need, the third pillar is the simplest. You don’t pitch. You don’t list every feature and benefit and hope one of them lands. You say: ‘We specialise in solving exactly that problem.’
Those words are more powerful than most founders realise. They signal that you understand the person in front of you, that you’ve done this before, and that you’re not trying to fit a square peg into a round hole.
The more you can back this up with a real story, a specific person, situation or outcome, the more credible and compelling it becomes. Not a vague case study, but a real narrative. Someone who was in the exact same position, made this decision, and here’s what happened next. That story does the emotional heavy lifting, so you don’t have to.
The key shift in mindset is moving from ‘I’m trying to sell this person something’ to ‘I’m trying to help this person solve a problem.’ It sounds subtle. But the effect on your conversion rate is not.
Pillar Four: Create a Reason to Act Now
The final pillar is often the most neglected. You’ve built trust, uncovered the need, shown how you can help and then you wait. The customer says they’ll think about it, and the energy quietly deflates.
People are busy. They get distracted. They come back to their desk on Monday and the feeling has faded. There has to be a gentle mechanism that says: the time to decide is now.
The most effective technique David shared is the three-option close. Rather than asking ‘would you like to go ahead?’, which forces a yes/no decision, you offer three options at different levels and ask which works best for them. The question in the customer’s mind shifts from ‘do I need this?’ to ‘which of these is right for me?’ and that’s an entirely different psychological state. Most people, given three options, choose the middle one.
From there, the close should be warm and immediate. Confirm what’s been agreed, tell them exactly what happens next, and send a clear confirmation covering only what’s been discussed. Don’t include additional information or new offers that invite them to reconsider. The decision has already been made.
Putting It All Together
The four pillars function as a sequence, not a menu. You can’t skip straight to the close if you haven’t built trust. You can’t help someone effectively if you haven’t understood their emotional need. And you can’t create urgency if the person doesn’t yet feel the solution is right for them.
As you get more practice, you’ll learn to read where any given prospect is in the process and respond accordingly. Some people will move through all four stages in a single conversation. Others will need more time at the trust stage. The skill is knowing where you are and not moving faster than the other person is ready for.
A well-mapped sales process in your CRM, with clear stages, dates, and next steps, means you’re never relying on memory or instinct alone. The system drives the process, and it’s your job is to bring the human element that no system can replicate.
4 Things to Implement This Week
- Measure your conversion rate – set it up on your KPI dashboard, broken down by lead type. You can’t improve what you don’t track.
- Map your sales process – write out the steps from first inquiry to close. Does each step move the prospect through one of the four pillars? Where are the gaps?
- Write your emotional questions – before your next sales call, prepare two or three questions designed to uncover what the person really wants, not just what they’re asking for.
- Try the three-option close – instead of asking ‘would you like to proceed?’, present three options at different levels and ask which one works best for them.
*****
We’re grateful, as always, to David for bringing such a rich and practically grounded session to our mastermind members. If you’d like access to monthly sessions like these, or a 1-2-1 with an expert advisor who can help you strengthen your own sales process, visit our memberships page.
